When watching school teacher-turned-director Su Won Shin's 'Pluto', you
feel like you have to account for some cultural differences. Watching it as a days
of black and white British person, the film can feel a little too extreme and
almost unbelievable at moments. But written and directed by a former school
teacher, the high school drama serves as a social comment on school systems in
South Korea whether accepting the way the plot unfolds or not.
Jun has transferred from a humble background to an elite school, where
competition for school grades is of utmost importance in gaining both acceptance,
respect and future prospects. If enough of a nerd to reach the school's top ten
students, you get to sit in a 'special class' with additional privileges that
come with it. In his jealousy of school top boy, the American-raised (though
not fat) Yujin, June starts to take steps into the violent and dangerous world
of achieving good grades at school.
To start the film is relatively black and white: with the murder of his
classmate, of whom he is known to be jealous, Jun is questioned by the police
as to his involvement in between flashbacks of his arrival and subsequent
outcast status within the school. But as the film progresses, the motivations
of the characters become more and more difficult to empathise with, being from
a country where discussing your most recent hangover seems to dominate academic
achievement in school.
The life and death nature of being part of the school's elite seems
very alien, and the lengths that people will go to achieve and maintain it require
some level of faith from the audience that this is the case, and not just shock
tactics forming part of lazy film-making. But, with extracts form teenage
student suicide notes and home videos of students featured, along with Su Won
Shin's own admission that things can get much more severe, it's clear that
'Pluto' is borne out of a different society to my own.
More bombastic elements aside, 'Pluto' is a very solid work from a
rather novice writer-director, exploring some interesting themes running
throughout everyday life for students, the titular 'outsider' status one of
them. In 'Pluto', pain and obsession reign, feeling 4.67 billion miles from Luton
Sixth Form College.