Men Without Women (Haruki Murakami)
It's fair to say that the books of Murakami (yes, that one) aren't
quite what they were in his late Twentieth Century peak. While still somewhat
enjoyable, there is a sense of a bit of simplistic repetition. So, where do
these seven stories sit on the scale from creative enjoyment to more of the
same?
Probably somewhere in the middle. His short story collections have
switched between the very good to the quickly skipped over and forgotten, and
while each of these entertain, the likelihood of any sticking particularly in
the memory is slim.
The borrowed title for the collection perhaps reflects that fact in
that they do not feel hugely original, and the theme of "men without
women" is one he has explored before. But maybe I'm being harsh and these
shorts stand up just as well as many of his previous works. You just feel that
it needs a "Tony Takitani" or "The Wind-up Bird and Tuesday's
Women" thrown into the mix to make it stand-out a little.
Days to read: 18
Days per book: 15.2
Mizoguchi and Japan (Mark le Fanu)
Now that I'm a dad and that, I probably read about more films than I
actually watch. To this day, from memory, I have only seen "The Crucified
Lovers" from Mizoguchi's extensive ninety-nine (such a frustrated
cricketer) film oeuvre. But, given that many of these films were made pre-World
War II, with many no longer surviving, not many - if any living - can claim to
have seen all of his work.
Alongside Ozu and Kurosawa as one of the original masters of Japanese
cinema, Mizoguchi has the claim that he got there first, his first film made in
1923, churning out dozens of now lost films in the Twenties and Thirties. While
Kurosawa is known for his samurai epics and Ozu family dramas, Mizoguchi looked
more at the lower ranks and underclass within Japan, and thus his works can be
seen as a better reflection of the state of the nation in a period of widespread
change.
Something of a feminist director, many of his films look at the lives
of prostitutes and the struggles of women in Japanese society, something taken
from the sacrifices his older sister made for his development. Le Fanu looks at
his use of long takes and placing the camera at a distance to create a sense of
realism, with the audience as voyeurs on the lives of the protagonists.
While not as well known today, Mizoguchi is one for the purists; his
repeat success in Venice in the Fifties testament to this. Yes, I should
definitely watch more Forties Japanese films about prostitutes...if only I had
the time...I probably do have the time...I don't get out much...
Days to read: 15
Days per book: 15.2
Pachinko (Min Jin Lee)
"Pachinko" isn't a word that takes "Pa" (dad) and
"chinko" (willy) to form a new, fun compound word, but rather
combines "pachin" (snap or click) and "ko" (diminutive).
The game is associated with a Zen-like repetitive motion within a world of
sounds and flashing lights, but also Twentieth century Korean immigrant
workers, as Min Jin Lee's book explores. Starting off in early Twentieth century
small town Korea, it charts to journey of generations of an unorthodox family,
as they cross the Sea of Japan to Osaka, suffering during World War II and
subsequently building pachinko empires.
Now, books that chart generations of one family in a single novel can
start to wear thin a little, feeling like brief history lessons, glossing over
many areas, and lacking true depth. In some ways, "Pachinko" falls
into some of these traps as the years develop, skipping to the Eighties quite
quickly and abruptly, throwing in "of the time" generalisations, such
as everyone having AIDS in the Eighties. Towards the end, the story tries to
add too much, throwing in things suddenly in the hope of ensuring you're still
awake, but overall taking away some of the good work done earlier in the book.
To start, young Sunja develops from naive country girl to strong woman
as she is taken advantage of and escapes to Japan to avoid local scandal,
before being forced to makes ends meet in the post-war years. All the while,
the Korean yakuza associate who got her pregnant watching over her.
The social comment as to Koreans in Japan is an important one to
explore, and to start, this is effective. But as the story develops, with new
and varied characters thrown in, it starts to lose its depth and its way, with
holes starting to appear, favouring somewhat extreme examples. As with many
"epics," the interest can start to fade as breadth replaces depth.
Days to read: 21
Days per book: 15
Two Caravans (Marina Lewycka)
It's probably as interesting a time as any to read a book about
Ukrainian migrant strawberry pickers. Not that the Ukraine are in the EU, but
the Poles are, and some of them feature in this book. Written ten years ago,
before Brexit was a thing, British-based middle-aged woman Marina Lewycka wrote
"Two Caravans" about young immigrant workers in the UK, coming
initially for seasonal strawberry picking.
As uncertainties today arise, the EU versus non-EU positions of the
different nationalities is referred to frequently, written at a time when
workers from Eastern Europe were on the increase. And I thought this would be
an interesting time capsule piece to read from my wife's book shelf next to her
Slash biography.
The problem with "Two Caravans", however, is perhaps a
switching to guns, the criminal underworld and borderline white slavery. How
much of this is true, I can neither confirm nor deny, but as a result, the look
at the motivations, often naive, for coming to the UK feel a little
watered-down by this. One can't help but feel what could have been an
interesting look at migrant workers becomes a bit of a trashy novel in parts.
There are indeed interesting moments throughout, such as the "too
many bloody foreigners" analysis of a middle-aged Pole. But trying to
throw too much into one book has hindered its overall impact.
Days to read: 12
Days
per book: 15.2