Three years later, the producers of
"Ten Years" have moved towards other Asian countries, with a trilogy
of "Ten Years Thailand", "Ten Years Taiwan" and "Ten
Years Japan". The latter (the one I watched), executive produced by respected
film man Kore-eda Hirokazu, is made in the same vein, looking at themes that
are universal, but are specific to Japan at the same time.
The first, fourth and fifth films are
more specific to current Japanese anxieties:
"Plan 75" (directed by Chie
Hayakawa) is a gentle pace-setter, looking at concerns of Japan's ageing
population. The problem no secret to the world, the "Plan 75" scheme
is a government-sanctioned euthanasia programme to offer a happy solution for
all. But when the scheme is taken up by a young employee of the scheme's
mother-in-law, his pregnant wife is less than happy; and the reaction of a
young man as he sets up a stall at a train station show that this solution is full
with difficulties in an increasingly less-human political landscape.
"The Air We Can't See"
(directed by Akiyo Fujimura) is perhaps the weakest of the bunch, as humanity
is forced to live in underground bunkers, following a nuclear meltdown. Young
Mizuki wants nothing more than to see beyond the concrete walls that surround
her world, while her mother wants to keep her in a secure bubble. But while
recent tragedy make this a very real concern, futures where nature is taken
away from humans is one done many times before, making this a little bland, like
the walls surrounding Mizuki's days.
The final short, "For Our Beautiful
Country" (directed by Kei Ishikawa) has the return of Japanese militarism
at heart, and is one of the stronger pieces on display. A poster for recruitment
for the war effort is deemed too old fashioned by the Ministry of Defence, and
a young advertising exec is sent to the house of the ageing designer to tell her the bad news. But instead of an awkward
conversation, he is treated to food and video games with a playful old lady and
daughter of a war veteran. She is well aware of why he has come and it was her
intention all along the make her design unappealing to the young. War is not
something she wants advertised.
The second and third segments are more
universal themes."Mischievous Alliance" (directed by Yusuke Kinoshita)
is straight out of "Black Mirror": school children signed up to a
scheme where they wear a headset that tracks their movements and behaviour. Big
Brother surveillance surrounding the grounds, the children's behaviour is
constantly monitored and messages designed to shape their future careers are pumped
into their minds at all times. The imminent death of the school horse prompts
one boy to rebel against it and its consequences. A clear dig at Japanese
school systems, this is perhaps one school day not to be too fondly remembered.
"Data" (directed by Megumi
Tsuno) again has "Black Mirror" at heart. A young girl whose mother
has died starts to get anxious as to the mother she never knew when her father
wants her to meet the new woman in his life. A data passport allows you to "inherit"
the social media data of the owner. As such, she opens up a can of worms, seeing
words and images without context. Discovering things she wished she probably
hadn't, she begins to question her own life and situation. Her father, seemingly
well prepared for this, helps her see that real relationships are better than
virtual ones.
As with the original "Ten
Years", it's a little bumpy, though the quality is perhaps more consistent
overall - the Hong Kong original switching between strong works to the down-right
bizarre. But made on a budget with novice filmmakers, this is to be expected. Also,
with only an average of around twenty minutes, ideas cannot be fully explored
and formed, making the more simple ideas, such as "Data", work more effectively
at getting their point across.
One thing that is noticeable with
"Ten Years Japan", however, is that while the Hong Kong original was
borne out of genuine political concerns, the Japanese version feels much more
like an extension of a successful idea. As such, the five stories feel more
like pilot ideas for "Black Mirror" rather than genuine political
statements about the way the world is turning. The ideas are at times clever,
but never cut too deep - as previously stated, feeling quite universal as
opposed to the more specific concerns affecting Hong Kong. Technology is more a
feature of anxieties here, as well as the demands of an ageing population and
increasing nationalist sentiment. Though these are themes that are hardly specific
to Japan alone.
But while not perfect, "Ten Years
Japan" has enough good ideas and filmmaking on display to get you
thinking. It's just that the thoughts here might be ones you've already had.
No comments:
Post a Comment