Recently watching Yukiko Mishima's"Dear Etranger" - where an everyday male is pushed to his limits, but rather than exploding violently, returns to a calm after a passive aggressive outburst - I was struck by the hero's choice to keep on the straight and narrow, rather than let that tension get the better of him. Based on the Haruki Murakami short "Barn Burning" (and also William Faulkner's story of the same name), "Peppermint Candy" director Lee Chang-dong chooses to let that tension out violently, allowing it to boil to an inevitable conclusion.
Adapting the character backgrounds, their interactions, however, are reasonably faithful to the original short. Jong-su (Yoo Ah-in) is somewhat of a lowly figure in Seoul. A farmer's son, he works low-level jobs while holding his ambition of becoming a writer. By chance he meets an old school friend from his farming village, Hae-mi (Jun Jong-seo) and the pair get chatting, meeting on several occasions before consummating their born-again friendship. But, having saved some money, she intends to travel to Africa, asking Jong-su to take care of her (non-existent) cat.
On her return, following an attack on the
airport in Nairobi, Hae-mi returns, though not alone. Asking him to meet her at
the airport, Jong-su is surprised to see her accompanied by the suave Ben
(Steven Yeun); the trio then going for a meal together. Intrigued by his
writing, Ben often accompanies Hae-mi whenever she meets up with Jong-su.
Though feeling uneasy about being the third wheel and out-of-place among Ben's high
society friends, Jong-su is also suspicious of Ben's wealth for one so young
and mysterious about his earnings.
His father imprisoned for a violent outburst, Jong-su has to return to his family farm to tend to its needs. It is on the farm, after smoking some weed together, that Ben reveals to Jong-su his passion for burning greenhouses: ones simply asking to be burnt down. This only adds to the man's mystery. Indicating that he has found his next "victim" nearby to Jong-su's farm, Jong-su is obsessive in trying to figure out which it will be. After receiving a call from a distressed Hae-mi, she subsequently disappears, leaving him to obsessively pursue Ben in order to find answers to both Hae-mi's whereabouts and the puzzle of the next greenhouse.
His father imprisoned for a violent outburst, Jong-su has to return to his family farm to tend to its needs. It is on the farm, after smoking some weed together, that Ben reveals to Jong-su his passion for burning greenhouses: ones simply asking to be burnt down. This only adds to the man's mystery. Indicating that he has found his next "victim" nearby to Jong-su's farm, Jong-su is obsessive in trying to figure out which it will be. After receiving a call from a distressed Hae-mi, she subsequently disappears, leaving him to obsessively pursue Ben in order to find answers to both Hae-mi's whereabouts and the puzzle of the next greenhouse.
The first thing to note about
"Burning" is that it is long. At two-and-a-half hours with a slow pace,
Lee allows a long of time for the suspense to rise, which he does well.
Jong-su's life is coming to a low point: his dad in prison, taking over a
failed farm and no clear career path or love life to speak of. Almost as if
researching for a novel, he plots the possibilities for Ben's next barn attack,
as well as staking out his home - this has become what he lives for. But the
length doesn't drag too much; come the end, you are searching for numerous
answers. "Burning", much like the Japanese short story, leads a lot
of open ends and leaves it up to you to piece them together.
Ben is the anti-Jong-su: successful, confident and full of mystery. Steven Yeun plays him adeptly; his time in America giving him an aura of the foreign in Jong-su's world. His charm and seeming boredom at Hae-mi - the nature of their relationship unclear, as it is with his subsequent love interest - make Jong-su question what his exact motives are, fuelled by his story of burning greenhouses. Was this merely a stoned prank, or is there a much more sinister man lying beneath? He is fully under Jong-su's skin.
Ben is almost calling Jong-su to act. A man of mystery, he seems as if he doesn't even know himself, living the high life, but without any real purpose. As in his interview in Sight & Sound, Lee wanted to show the difficulties for today's youth in South Korea. Jong-su has nothing but intentions and feels unable to act on them; while Ben has everything but no sense of purpose. Jong-su's final act is the rage of the have-nots against the haves.
The ending may feel somewhat inevitable
by the time it comes, but much like Jong-su's obsession, the longer you leave
it and the more you mull it over, the more intriguing it gets. Having re-read
the short after, as well as adding the ending, Lee adds a greater sense of
mystery, obsession and social comment. What starts as a burning candle,
explodes like a firework.